Wittenberg Door Campus Ministry
  • Home
    • Podcast Archives
  • About
    • About Wittenberg CoMo
    • Support Us
    • Subscribe
    • Contact Us
  • Resources
    • Greek Tutorials
  • Blog
  • Calendar
  • Sandbox

Source Citations

3/13/2015

0 Comments

 
Weston, Anthony. A Rulebook for Arguments. 4th ed. Indianapolis: Hackett Pub., 2009. Kindle Electronic Edition.
Chapter 4, “Sources” pp. 23-30

Weston observes that much of the information we have comes from a source outside ourselves. Because the sources we use may be more or less authoritative and more or less accurate, Weston gives us “a checklist of standards that truly authoritative sources need to meet” (Weston 2009, 23).

First (section 13), when a truth claim has very specific information associated with it, we should find and cite the source.

Second (section 14), sources cited should be credible. They need to have some sort of expertise in the field of study. “Where a source’s qualifications are not immediately clear, an argument must explain them briefly” (Weston, 24). Likewise, if a source of information has only fragmentary knowledge of a topic, it is good to be candid about that fact. This is what the best sources do in their own work. “Most good sources will offer at least some reasons or evidence - examples, facts, analogies, other kinds of arguments - to help explain and defend their conclusions” (Ibid., 25).

Third (section 15), sources who are impartial are normally the best source of information. Independent sources and sources which engage actual arguments are generally the most reliably impartial.

Fourth (section 16), sources of information should be compared. This process of cross-checking is valuable. Where there is little consensus it is more difficult to weigh information. Weston does grant that less tangible issues tend to be more immune to cross-checking. Weston’s footnote about climate change as a widely recognized issue is an intriguing example. The source he reports, from 2007, was fairly current and widely accepted at the time of the book’s publication in 2009. Since that time there have been discoveries about the preparation of the reported source which have eroded its credibility. He therefore unknowingly presented a very valid example of the need for ongoing cross-checking.

Fifth (section 17), Weston points out the caution which should be exercised in web searches. Some sources are not as reliable as others. Credibility of web sites can be weighed and evaluated.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    ​Help Fuel This Ministry by Clicking Here!

    All the work of Wittenberg Door Campus Ministry, including this blog, is supported by the generosity of people like you. Please consider joining our team of prayer and financial supporters. Read more here!
    Please Note: The opinions presented in blog posts are not necessarily those of Wittenberg Door Campus Ministry. Frequently we report on contrary views, often without comment. Please chime in on the discussion.

    About Throwing Inkwells

    When Martin Luther was dealing with struggles in his life he once saw what appeared to be an angelic being. Not trusting that he was going to be informed by someone other than the God revealed in Scripture, he took the appearance to be untrustworthy and hurled his inkwell at it. The chipped place in the plaster wall is still visible at the Wartburg Castle, though apparently the ink stain on the wall has been refreshed periodically by the caretaker.

    Blog Feeds

    RSS Feed

    Want to keep up with what's happening at Wittenberg Door? Subscribe to our mailing list!

    Categories

    All
    1 Corinthians
    1 John
    1 Peter
    1 Thessalonians
    1-timothy
    2 Corinthians
    2 Kings
    2 Peter
    2 Samuel
    2-thessalonians
    2-timothy
    Academic-success
    Acts
    Advent-1-a
    Advent 1B
    Advent-2-a
    Advent 2B
    Advent-3-a
    Advent 3B
    Advent-4-a
    Advent 4B
    Allitt-2010
    Amos
    Aristotle
    Baptism-of-christ
    Baptism Of The Lord B
    Belonging
    Bruce 1988
    Bruce-1988
    Canonicity
    Carson-1991
    Carson & Moo 2005
    Catholicism
    Christmas 1B
    Christmas-day
    Chronicles
    Circumcision-and-naming-of-christ
    Colossians
    Confessions
    Deuteronomy
    Didache
    Diversity
    Dix2005
    Dix-2005
    Easter-2a
    Easter-2b
    Easter-3a
    Easter 3B
    Easter-4a
    Easter 4B
    Easter-5a
    Easter 5B
    Easter-6a
    Easter-7a
    Easter B
    Easter-sunday-a
    Ecclesiastes
    Ephesians
    Epiphany-2-a
    Epiphany-3-a
    Epiphany-3b
    Epiphany-4-a
    Epiphany-4b
    Epiphany-5-a
    Epiphany-5b
    Epiphany-6-a
    Epiphany-7-a
    Esther
    Eucharist
    Exodus
    Exodus-20
    Ezekiel
    Ezra
    Fagerberg1988
    Fagerberg-1988
    Forde-2007
    Galatians
    Genesis
    Gonzalez-2010
    Habakkuk
    Hebrews
    Henderson-1992
    History
    Infertility
    Isaiah
    James
    Jeremiah
    Job
    John
    Jonah
    Joshua
    Judges
    Justin-martyr
    Kings
    Kleinig-2013
    Kolb-2000
    Kolb-2000
    Kolbarand2008
    Kolb-arand-2008
    Last-sunday-of-the-church-year-a
    Last-sunday-of-the-church-year-c
    Lectionary
    Lent-1-a
    Lent-1b
    Lent-2-a
    Lent-2b
    Lent-3-a
    Lent-3b
    Lent-4-a
    Lent-4b
    Lent-5-a
    Lent-5b
    Lessing-2014
    Lessing-2014
    Leviticus
    Long-2009
    Luke
    Luther
    Maas-2014
    Malachi
    Mark
    Marty-2016
    Matthew
    Mcknight-2014
    Micah
    Mitch-2010
    Morris-1992
    Nehemiah
    Newtestament
    New Testament
    Numbers
    Old Testament
    Old-testament
    Ordination
    Orphan-hosting
    Osborne-2013
    Ozment1980
    Ozment-1980
    Palm-sunday-a
    Passionb
    Pentateuch
    Pentecost-10a
    Pentecost-11a
    Pentecost-12a
    Pentecost-13a
    Pentecost-14a
    Pentecost-15
    Pentecost-15a
    Pentecost-16
    Pentecost-16a
    Pentecost-17a
    Pentecost-18a
    Pentecost-18-c
    Pentecost-19a
    Pentecost-19-c
    Pentecost-1a
    Pentecost-20a
    Pentecost-20-c
    Pentecost-21a
    Pentecost-21-c
    Pentecost-22a
    Pentecost-22-c
    Pentecost-23a
    Pentecost-23-c
    Pentecost-24a
    Pentecost-24-c
    Pentecost-25-c
    Pentecost-26-c
    Pentecost-2a
    Pentecost-3a
    Pentecost-4a
    Pentecost-5a
    Pentecost-6a
    Pentecost-7a
    Pentecost-8a
    Pentecost-9a
    Peterson2010
    Peterson-2010
    Philemon
    Philippians
    Philosophy
    Pieper1924
    Pieper-1924
    Preaching
    Prophets
    Proverbs
    Psalm
    Quintilian
    Receptivity
    Reformation
    Rhetoric
    Romans
    Ruth
    Sailhamer1992
    Sailhamer-1992
    Samuel
    Scaer2004
    Scaer-2004
    Schaff-2014
    Schaff-2014
    Sermon
    Smith-2009
    Song-of-songs
    Teaching
    Thielman-2010
    Transfiguration-a
    Transfigurationb
    Trinity-a
    Weston-2009
    Wilson2011
    Wilson-2011
    Wilson20113470b5cf10
    Zechariah
    Zephaniah

Proudly powered by Weebly
✕